Reform UK has announced a radical immigration plan that promises to deport up to 600,000 migrants over five years if the party secures power at the next election. Party leader Nigel Farage insists that this is a “credible plan” to restore Border Control, an issue that has dominated political debate since before the Brexit referendum.
The Brexit Context: A Promise of Control
The decision to leave the European Union was heavily driven by concerns about immigration. Voters were told Brexit would allow the UK to “take back control” of its borders, free from EU rules on freedom of movement. Yet nearly a decade later, the picture is more complex.
While visa applications across categories such as work and study have declined due to tighter post-Brexit rules, irregular migration has sharply increased. Home Office figures show that more than hundred thousand people have entered the UK illegally since 2020, mostly via small boats across the Channel. This trend has not only undermined the original Brexit promise but has also fuelled public frustration about government competence.
Labour’s Promises and the Rising Tide of Illegal Migration
Since coming to power in 2024, Labour has pledged to smash the smuggling gangs that facilitate small boat crossings. Ministers have also announced a pilot “one in, one out” deal with France, under which the UK will return migrants while accepting an equal number of vetted asylum seekers.
However, these measures have not stemmed the tide. Channel crossings continue to reach record highs, with 28,288 people making the journey so far this year, 46% more than in the same period in 2024. Meanwhile, asylum applications have climbed to a record 111,000 in the year to June. The contradiction is stark: official migration routes are being restricted, but illegal arrivals are increasing. The result is mounting pressure on housing, social services and communities, with asylum seekers placed in hotels sparking legal challenges and protests in towns across the UK.
Policy on Paper, Chaos in Practice?
While the “one in, one out” pilot has been presented as a balanced and fair solution, its effectiveness remains uncertain. There is no guarantee that those returned under the agreement will not attempt to re-enter the UK through irregular routes, raising doubts about whether the scheme can deliver long-term results. Critics have also drawn comparisons to the Rwanda plan introduced by the previous government, which sought to deter Channel crossings by relocating asylum seekers abroad. That policy was eventually abandoned when Labour took office, though other European countries, such as Italy, have pursued similar offshore processing models through their agreement with Albania.
Beyond the question of border control, there are growing concerns about wider abuses of the system. Critics argue that loopholes within both immigration and welfare processes are being exploited, placing additional strain on public resources. Meanwhile, the tightening of rules has had unintended consequences for genuine applicants and legitimate businesses, who often face heavier compliance obligations and longer processing times. This has created a situation where those who follow the rules are burdened, while those operating outside the system continue to test its weaknesses.
On paper, these new measures appear robust, but the real question is whether they will work in practice. Voters were told during the Brexit campaign that leaving the EU would allow Britain to “take back control” of its borders. Nearly a decade on, that promise has not been fully realised. The concern now is whether Labour’s latest pledges risk repeating the same cycle: strong words and bold plans, but little real change on the ground.
Reform UK’s “Mass Deportation” Bill
Farage’s answer to this crisis is the proposed Illegal Migration (Mass Deportation) Bill. Key features include:
- A legal duty on the Home Secretary to remove illegal migrants.
- A lifetime ban on re-entry for anyone deported.
- Construction of new removal centres to hold up to 24,000 people.
- Expansion of deportation flights to five per day.
- £2,500 incentives for voluntary return.
- Agreements with countries like Rwanda, Albania, and even UK overseas territories to host migrants.
The party estimates the plan would cost £10 billion over five years but argues it would save money in the long term currently spent on asylum hotels.
A Country Still Searching for Control
Nearly ten years after Brexit, Britain finds itself in a paradox. Legal migration channels have narrowed, yet illegal migration has surged. Streets in many towns now reflect the strain, with visible homelessness, rough sleeping and community tensions rising. The government insists it is working to regain control, but its disorganised policies appear ineffective against the scale of the crisis.
Reform UK is tapping into the public’s frustration by promising to do what successive governments have failed to achieve: reassert genuine control of the border. Yet the question remains whether Farage’s pledges are achievable, or whether they risk becoming yet another unfulfilled promise in the long, troubled history of Britain’s immigration debate.
It is worth remembering that the entire Brexit campaign was built on the promise of regaining Border Control. Nearly a decade later, the reality tells a different story, with illegal crossings and asylum claims reaching record highs despite repeated pledges of tougher enforcement. This raises a crucial question: can the public place their faith in Farage’s campaign without risking a repeat of the Brexit experience, bold promises made at the ballot box, only for voters to find that the outcome delivered something very different from what they were told?
With over 20 years of experience and a commitment to excellence, Morgan Smith Immigration is your trusted partner for all your immigration needs. Contact us today to learn more about how we can assist you with UK Visa Applications. For any enquiries or assistance, call us at 0203 959 3335 or email [email protected].
